{"meta":{"id":"https:\/\/api.iclient.ifeng.com\/ipadtestdoc?aid=ucms_7weGpd5F5Hz","type":"doc","o":"1","documentId":"ucms_7weGpd5F5Hz"},"body":{"newStatus":"1","documentId":"ucms_7weGpd5F5Hz","staticId":"ucms_7weGpd5F5Hz","title":"刘备当初派去守荆州的若不是关羽,而是赵云,荆州还会丢么?","shareTitle":"刘备当初派去守荆州的若不是关羽,而是赵云,荆州还会丢么?","thumbnail":"http:\/\/d.ifengimg.com\/w150_h106_q100\/x0.ifengimg.com\/res\/2020\/B474D5E6312CB8E16A5CBFF60B44862AE3784662_size34_w641_h401.jpeg","source":"送历史个救生圈","author":"","editorcode":"weMedia","editTime":"2020-05-21 09:38:44","updateTime":"2020\/05\/21 09:38:44","wapurl":"http:\/\/\/\/history.ifeng.com\/c\/7weGpd5F5Hz","introduction":"","wwwurl":"http:\/\/\/\/history.ifeng.com\/c\/7weGpd5F5Hz","commentsUrl":"ucms_7weGpd5F5Hz","commentCount":0,"hasVideo":"Y","text":"
大家都知道,关羽一生侠肝义胆,武艺高强,为世人所敬重。他帮着刘备打下了蜀汉江山,又坐镇荆州,可以说是劳苦功高。但刘备可以说是“成也关羽,败也关羽”。关羽虽然为他打下了大片疆土,但却因为骄傲的性格大意失荆州,不仅自己兵败身死,而且还牵连了张飞和刘备,最终导致蜀汉也开始走下坡路。有人不禁反问:“如果当初镇守荆州的不是关羽,而是别人,那蜀汉的命运会改变么?”小编今天就来和大家探讨一下。<\/p>
<\/p>
刘备插图<\/p>
刘备作为三国霸主之一,麾下除了关羽外,自然还有其他的猛将。后人将最厉害的五人合称为“五虎上将”,而蜀汉的五虎上将,分别是:关羽、张飞、赵云、马超和黄忠。除此之外,后起之秀魏延和军师诸葛亮的实力也不可小觑。如果刘备当初派出去守荆州的不是关羽,那谁会是最合适的人选呢?<\/p>
首先排除掉的便是张飞。张飞与关羽一样,都是刘备的结拜兄弟,在武力上也堪称“万人敌”。按理说,由他接替关羽的位置应该没啥问题,但刘备之前却从未考虑过此事。为何?因为刘备是自家人知自家事。张飞虽然与关羽相差无几,但却有个最大的毛病:“暴而无恩”!他常常在酒后鞭笞士兵,刘备为此说过他好多次。<\/p>
<\/p>
张飞插图<\/p>
关羽是怎么死的,大家应该都有所了解。就是因为骄傲自大,看不起孙权,苛责麋芳和士仁,导致他在与东吴交战的关键时刻被人背叛。张飞的毛病比关羽还要严重,所以才会在后来独掌兵权时被手下割掉首级。如果把荆州交到他的手里,可能早早就被孙权给夺回去了。<\/p>
其次排除掉的是马超和黄忠。刘备命关羽镇守荆州的时代背景是军师庞统阵亡后,当时他召张飞、赵云、诸葛亮入川支援,又担心老巢被人端了,所以才把关羽留下。后来他平定蜀地,就安排关羽镇守荆州五郡了。而马超是在后来才加入的,刘备对他的忠心还正在考察阶段,自然不会贸然将荆州这么重要的地方交给马超。至于黄忠,能力一般,也是后来投靠蜀汉,所以刘备也不会考虑。<\/p>
<\/p>
关羽插图<\/p>
最后,适合镇守荆州的是诸葛亮和赵云。当初刘备在入蜀时,最开始带的人并不是诸葛亮,而是庞统。是庞统突然间死了,刘备身边缺人,才将诸葛亮调了过去。倘若庞统没死,那派诸葛亮去守荆州将是最稳妥的办法。尽管诸葛亮不能像关羽等人一样亲自上阵杀敌,但让他守城应该是没有问题的。而且他一直奉行“交好东吴”的政策,有他在那里与东吴协商,蜀汉也不会与东吴成势同水火的关系,荆州自然不会轻易丢失。<\/p>
<\/p>
赵云插图<\/p>
而“常胜将军”赵子龙也是镇守荆州的一个合适人选。很多人都说赵云没有统率大军的经验,但在建安十八年,刘备与刘璋决裂后,急召诸葛亮等人入蜀。赵云便随张飞、诸葛亮率军溯江西上,一路平定郡县。在攻克江州后,他们兵分两路,赵云率军由外水深入,攻取江阳、犍为等郡,次年在成都南面,完成对刘璋的包围。可见,赵云的军事素养并不差,只是缺少机会罢了。而且他为人重义轻利,对手下视如手足,又听命行事。如果刘备派他守荆州,虽谈不上万无一失,但绝不会轻易丢失。<\/p>
参考资料:《三国志》、《后汉书》<\/p>","img":[{"url":"http:\/\/d.ifengimg.com\/mw640_q100\/x0.ifengimg.com\/res\/2020\/B474D5E6312CB8E16A5CBFF60B44862AE3784662_size34_w641_h401.jpeg","size":{"width":"640","height":"400"}},{"url":"http:\/\/d.ifengimg.com\/mw640_q100\/x0.ifengimg.com\/res\/2020\/E5C652AB0AA8D3C06632706699E19082CBE5C323_size40_w641_h401.jpeg","size":{"width":"640","height":"400"}},{"url":"http:\/\/d.ifengimg.com\/mw640_q100\/x0.ifengimg.com\/res\/2020\/872845AD3A37808FAA104CA30C9D4B347EB5ADC8_size36_w641_h401.jpeg","size":{"width":"640","height":"400"}},{"url":"http:\/\/d.ifengimg.com\/mw640_q100\/x0.ifengimg.com\/res\/2020\/371033DAA89A7CABACFA44B9E9B6BD1FF5068BB8_size29_w641_h401.jpeg","size":{"width":"640","height":"400"}}],"summary":"大家都知道,关羽一生侠肝义胆,武艺高强,为世人所敬重。他帮着刘备打下了蜀汉江山,又坐镇荆州,可以说是劳苦功高。但刘备可以说是“成也关羽,败也关羽”。关羽虽然为他","sharesummary":"大家都知道,关羽一生侠肝义胆,武艺高强,为世人所敬重。他帮着刘备打下了蜀汉江山,又坐镇荆州,可以说是劳苦功高。但刘备可以说是“成也关羽,败也关羽”。关羽虽然为他","videoPoster":"http:\/\/d.ifengimg.com\/mw640_q100\/x0.ifengimg.com\/res\/2020\/575E4D91D8E0D483BF7FB12F4ADD933D579B6F1B_size54_w1280_h720.jpg","videoSrc":"","videos":[{"guid":"137a623b-a50e-46b9-a4ee-054c91c53743","staticId":"video_137a623b-a50e-46b9-a4ee-054c91c53743","columnId":"","duration":"00:02:26","title":"刘备当初派去守荆州的若不是关羽,而是赵云,荆州还会丢么?","thumbnail":"http:\/\/d.ifengimg.com\/w480_h360_q100\/x0.ifengimg.com\/res\/2020\/575E4D91D8E0D483BF7FB12F4ADD933D579B6F1B_size54_w1280_h720.jpg","thumbnailSize":{"width":"480","height":"360"},"video":{"Normal":{"src":"http:\/\/ips.ifeng.com\/video19.ifeng.com\/video09\/2020\/05\/21\/p35806270-102-9987636-094225.mp4?ifsign=1","fileSize":""},"HD":{"src":"http:\/\/ips.ifeng.com\/video19.ifeng.com\/video09\/2020\/05\/21\/p35806270-102-9987636-094225.mp4?ifsign=1","fileSize":""}},"videoAppDesc":"凤凰视频客户端","android_downloadurl":"http:\/\/dl.app.ifengcdn.com\/ifengapps\/20190920\/IfengVideo_aPhone_V7.6.7_1909191357_12031.apk","relation":[]}],"commentType":"0","wemediaEAccountId":"907462","showclient":"0","shareurl":"https:\/\/ishare.ifeng.com\/c\/s\/v002vmFgN0VTMCVca9jVm31AY5RMLLYtmKCnkpdsgDcB7bk__","praise":"4","like_num":"4"}}